Why doesn't widgets show

I'm trying to add a widget to my home page. And it keeps telling me to log in and add widgets to this page. I have 2 already on the page. I've looked at it under two different user profiles and still see nothing. I can add widgets to other pages.

I've disabled membership currently because I have to figure out how it all interacts. I think I did have some settings blocked but I'm assuming if it's deactivated I am not being affected.

1) I'm logged in as superadmin when I add the widget.
2) I'm signed in as a subscriber and widgets aren't showing.