With Membrership Login Directs To Protected Content page

I am using Membership on several sites (not as multisite). Each site is experiencing the same thing. Upon login, the page shows a Protected Content splash screen. I saw in some posts that Membership as a Redirect On Login option but I cannot find that anywhere. I feel that may have been the earlier Membership, while I am using Membership 2. Before I go the whole nine yards and give you back door access to the site is there a quick fix for a known issue here? I believe I am only using positive rules for all membership types: if you are Level 2 these pages show. So, I don't think I have a conflict in the rules going on.

Thanks,
Ethan