WordPress Privacy

When I set the site privacy to

"Visitors must have a login – anyone that is a registered user of Scholastic Sites can gain access. "

It works the way its supposed to,

but the sites dont show up under all sites page, whats the best way to approach this, I want only logged in users to be able to access any site. but the logged in users should be able to see all the other sites under the sites page and be able to search for them as well.