WPMU Membership, S2Member, MagicMembers or Wishlist which is better

How is WPMU Membership compared to S2Member, MagicMembers and Wishlist Members?. I would like to know which one is best to use in collaboration with ClickBank

  • theIMgeek
    • WPMU DEV Initiate

    I recently tried Wishlist to compare against WPMU's Membership. In the end, I stuck with WPMU. Wishlist looks good but the thing that got me was the lack of control over menus and sidebars for members.

    I guess WPMU seemed more versatile and flexible to me.


  • Arun Basil Lal
    • New Recruit

    Hello maitlandd,

    Now that is a hard question.

    I have used the Wishlist member a long time ago and I would say, No No, we are way better. Its been almost an year, so am not sure how things are now.

    No experience with Magic Members here.

    S2Member is good enough as a free solution. But if you compare that to Membership 3.0. Again, Membership 3.0 wins.

    Okay, I have been biased here, I have been using Membership a lot lately and maybe its my favorite at the moment.

    I am interested in the context of this question as well. Let me know?

Thank NAME, for their help.

Let NAME know exactly why they deserved these points.

Gift a custom amount of points.